Charcoal vs. Gas vs. Pellet Grills: How to Choose
This page may contain affiliate links. Some links on this site may be affiliate links, and we may earn a commission from affiliate programs at no extra cost to you.
Choosing a grill usually comes down to one question: how much do you value convenience versus hands-on cooking and flavor? Charcoal, gas and pellet grills all make excellent food. They differ in how quickly they heat up, how much attention they need, how much they cost to run and how well they handle low-and-slow smoking. Here is a plain-language comparison.
| Photo | Product | Best For | Key Spec | Price | Shop |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 | Charbroil Performance Series 4-Burner Gas Grill with FlavorMax | Best Overall | 35,000 BTU 4-burner output | ~$299 10% Off 1st Order Signup | View Deal → |
 | Charbroil Kettleman TRU-Infrared Charcoal Grill | Runner-Up Pick | 22.5-in TRU-Infrared grate | ~$200 10% Off 1st Order Signup | View Deal → |
 | Charbroil Vertical Gas Smoker | Midwest Tested | 365 sq. in. across 3 chrome racks | ~$350 10% Off 1st Order Signup | View Deal → |
 | Charbroil 22" Performance Series Portable Tabletop 2-Burner Gas Griddle | Reader Favorite | Dual-zone cold-rolled steel top | ~$149 10% Off 1st Order Signup | View Deal → |
 | Charbroil Universal Grill Rotisserie Kit | Midwest Tested | Electric motor + 1-piece rod | ~$70 10% Off 1st Order Signup | View Deal → |
 | Charbroil Universal Large Grill Cover | Best Value | Sealed-seam all-weather fabric | ~$35 10% Off 1st Order Signup | View Deal → |
Charcoal grills
Charcoal grills are simple and affordable, and they reach high searing temperatures. They are also versatile: by arranging coals on one side, you can cook with direct and indirect heat, and with some practice you can smoke ribs or a pork shoulder. The trade-offs are a longer warm-up (a chimney starter takes about fifteen to twenty minutes) and ash clean-up.
Lump charcoal lights faster and burns hotter, while briquettes burn more evenly and predictably. Many people keep both.
Weber Original Kettle 22-inch
A classic charcoal kettle with a vented lid, adjustable dampers and an ash catcher. It is widely used, parts are easy to find, and it can handle both grilling and basic smoking.
Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker
A bullet-style charcoal smoker designed specifically for low-and-slow cooking, available in several sizes.
Kamado-style grills (Big Green Egg, Kamado Joe)
Thick ceramic grills that hold heat very efficiently and can grill, smoke and roast. They are heavy and expensive but very versatile.
Gas grills
Gas grills are the convenience choice: turn a knob, press the igniter and you are cooking in about ten to fifteen minutes. Multiple burners make it easy to set up zones. They are well suited to weeknight cooking. Flavor differences compared with charcoal are noticeable to some people and not to others; smoke tubes or smoker boxes can add wood flavor.
When comparing gas grills, look at build quality (heavier grates and burners last longer), the number of burners, and warranty length rather than headline BTU numbers alone. Decide between propane tanks and a natural gas connection if your home has a gas line.
Weber Spirit or Genesis series
Popular gas grills with long warranties and good parts availability. The Spirit line is mid-priced; Genesis models add more cooking space and features.
Char-Broil Performance series
A budget-friendly gas grill line. Good value, though lighter-duty materials may not last as long as higher-end grills.
Napoleon Rogue or Prestige series
Mid-to-upper priced gas grills often noted for sturdy construction, with some models offering infrared side or rear burners.
Pellet grills
Pellet grills burn compressed hardwood pellets fed by an auger and controlled by a digital thermostat. You set a temperature and the grill holds it, which makes smoking brisket or ribs much easier. Many connect to an app. They need electricity, have more parts that can wear out, and traditionally do not sear as hot as charcoal or gas, though some newer models have added searing features.
Traeger Pro or Ironwood series
One of the best-known pellet grill brands, with app-connected models and a wide range of sizes.
Pit Boss pellet grills
Often priced lower than comparable Traeger models, with models that include a direct-flame searing option.
Recteq pellet grills
Known for sturdy steel construction and Wi-Fi controllers.
Where to buy
These are specific grills and accessories available from a retailer we partner with. We have not tested them; compare them against the advice above before buying.
Charbroil Performance Series 4-Burner Gas Grill with FlavorMax
35,000-BTU 4-burner propane grill with porcelain-coated cast-iron grates for even heat across 435 sq. in. of primary cooking space.
- 35,000 BTU 4-burner output
- Porcelain cast-iron grates
- Season cast-iron surfaces and cover between snowy cookouts
Charbroil Kettleman TRU-Infrared Charcoal Grill
22.5-inch kettle charcoal grill with porcelain-coated no-fall-through grates, oversized damper control, and hinged lid.
- 22.5-in TRU-Infrared grate
- 360° air intake & oversized damper
- Season cast-iron surfaces and cover between snowy cookouts
Charbroil Vertical Gas Smoker
365 sq. in. vertical propane smoker with three adjustable chrome grates, large wood-chip & water pan, and double-drawer access.
- 365 sq. in. across 3 chrome racks
- Double-drawer chip & water access
- Season cast-iron surfaces and cover between snowy cookouts
Charbroil 22" Performance Series Portable Tabletop 2-Burner Gas Griddle
Dual-zone 22-inch cold-rolled steel portable propane griddle that runs on 1 lb camp cylinders or a 20 lb tank with adapter.
- Dual-zone cold-rolled steel top
- Runs on 1 lb or 20 lb propane
- Season cast-iron surfaces and cover between snowy cookouts
Charbroil Universal Grill Rotisserie Kit
One-piece motorized rotisserie rod with two 4-prong meat forks that fits most 2- to 6-burner gas and charcoal grills.
- Electric motor + 1-piece rod
- Dual 4-prong heavy meat forks
- Season cast-iron surfaces and cover between snowy cookouts
Charbroil Universal Large Grill Cover
Heavy-duty sealed-seam weather cover with side closure straps for protecting 3- to 4-burner grills through Midwest winters.
- Sealed-seam all-weather fabric
- Side closure wind straps
- Season cast-iron surfaces and cover between snowy cookouts
Cost of running
Charcoal costs vary by how often you cook and how much fuel you use. Propane is generally inexpensive per cook, and natural gas lines are cheaper still. Pellet costs depend on the length of your cooks; long smokes use more pellets.
Midwest weather considerations
If you grill year-round, consider how a grill performs in cold and wind. Kamado and insulated pellet grills hold temperature better in winter; insulated blankets are available for many pellet models. A cover protects any grill from snow and rain. Always grill outdoors, away from garages and overhangs.
Which should you choose?
Choose charcoal if you enjoy the process, want high searing heat and want the lowest price of entry. Choose gas if you want quick weeknight dinners with minimal fuss. Choose pellet if you want to smoke meats regularly with a set-it-and-check-it approach. Many backyard cooks eventually own two: a gas grill for weeknights and a charcoal kettle or pellet smoker for weekends.
The bottom line
There is no single best grill, just the best fit for how you cook. Whatever you choose, a good meat thermometer is the most useful add-on. Match the fuel to your schedule, buy from a brand with good parts availability and warranty support, and add a good instant-read thermometer, which matters more than any grill feature.
Frequently asked questions
What is the main difference between charcoal, gas and pellet grills?
Gas grills heat up in 10 to 15 minutes with push-button convenience for weeknight meals, charcoal grills offer high searing heat and classic smoke flavor at a lower upfront cost, and pellet grills use digital temperature control for easy low-and-slow smoking.
Are flat-top gas griddles good for camping and backyard cooking?
Yes. A portable propane tabletop griddle cooks smash burgers, pancakes, bacon, stir-fries and fajitas evenly without food falling through grill grates.